I write this as I travel to Birmingham to participate in a panel discussion with Nick Shackleton-Jones and Robin Hoyle on the role of social media in learning. The discussion forms part of the agenda for the World of Learning Conference, an event that I have enjoyed participating in for something like ten years now. Anyway, this post provides me with an opportunity to clarify my thoughts in preparation for the discussion.
There is no question whatsoever that social media is transforming our personal and business lives. I won't re-iterate the statistics because you know already what a fundamental difference it makes to be so connected so comprehensively and so continuously. Whether or not l&d professionals or senior managers embrace social media doesn't really matter in the long run, because there is no turning back, only futile resistance. The internet and mobile technologies are changing our lives as completely as the invention of writing, printing, the telephone and radio/TV have done in the past.
Should senior managers and those in l&d want to try and direct the use of social media to ensure a positive impact on learning and business performance, then there are at least four areas in which they can look:
Formal learning: There is considerable scope in longer, blended programmes, such as professional and postgraduate qualifications, and management development programmes to use social media as a vehicle for ongoing group collaboration:
- the use of forums to discuss issues and share ideas
- the use of blogs as learning journals
- the use of wikis for group collaborative projects
- sharing research using podcasts and videos
The exciting aspect of these approaches is in the changing role of online content, less as a top-down input from tutors and more of an output from students to be shared with peers. I have been using these techniques for something like five years now and have never encountered any resistance. In some cases the results have been transformational.
Non-formal learning: Social learning also has a place outside the scope of formal courses but still in the cause of ongoing personal development:
- the use of communities of practice to share new ideas and debate issues
- the use of micro-blogging to quickly update peers on new developments
On-demand learning: A great deal of learning takes place on-demand, at the point of need. Organisations can do their best to satisfy the needs of employees for on-demand information but they will rarely be able to cover it all on a top-down basis. The gaps can be filled using social media:
- the use of social networks to find sources of expertise or offer your own expertise to others
- content sharing (text, screencasts, podcasts, etc.) in the familiar YouTube fashion
Experiential learning: Learning at work is as much about 'learning from' as it is 'learning to'. We learn through our own experiences and the experiences of those around us, but only if we make a conscious effort to reflect. Here is where blogging can play a valuable role. I know this discipline will not be for everybody, but for those that really engage the opportunities for learning exceed all others.
We have got by without all these techniques in the past and many organisations will make a determined effort to get by without them in the future. They may do this with the best of intentions, but they will be missing opportunities, opportunities that their competitors may well be exploiting.
Great post and food for thought. I think organizations must find ways to capture every aspect of enterprise knowledge. When knowledge and information is optimized it most assuredly shortens the learning curve helping employees get up to speed quickly. Think of the impact on a new sales rep? I agree with you if we ignore it we will miss out on opportunities.
ReplyDeleteHi Clive,
ReplyDeleteAre there any compelling case studies into the effective application of social media based learning?
L&D professionals are pretty lax in measuring formal learning. It would be great understand who is exactly stretching the boundaries here and the impacts they have made.
D
Hi Clive,
ReplyDeleteGreat post - I would have delighted at attending the talk at WOLCE today but alas - other things cropped up.
I frequently hear misgivings about including social media into organisations' learning programmes. Some would like to embrace it but are faced with barriers from their senior managers, IT departments and colleagues. Some just don't get it and still only hear the biased views they hear from news reports on all the negative aspects (yes I know I'm biased the other way!). Some only see social media as a 'fun' thing to share what each other has had for tea.
Often I hear about the fears that staff will just waste their time 'socialising' and not getting any work done or share something they shouldn't. My response is usally along the lines of not blaming the tools but manage the people. Even before Jane Bozarth commented in her interview with Cammy Bean the other week (would we take all the e-mail out if someone used it inappropriately) I have said similar to my own delegates.
I'm sorry to say I remember when e-mail first was introduced where I worked - the fears were exactly the same and I bet they said the same about the contraption invented by Alexander Graham Bell! Now look where we are.
Yes - there is no stopping it so if you can't beat 'em, join 'em is what I say!
Hi Clive,
ReplyDeleteGreat post - I would have delighted at attending the talk at WOLCE today but alas - other things cropped up.
I frequently hear misgivings about including social media into organisations' learning programmes. Some would like to embrace it but are faced with barriers from their senior managers, IT departments and colleagues. Some just don't get it and still only hear the biased views they hear from news reports on all the negative aspects (yes I know I'm biased the other way!). Some only see social media as a 'fun' thing to share what each other has had for tea.
Often I hear about the fears that staff will just waste their time 'socialising' and not getting any work done or share something they shouldn't. My response is usally along the lines of not blaming the tools but manage the people. Even before Jane Bozarth commented in her interview with Cammy Bean the other week (would we take all the e-mail out if someone used it inappropriately) I have said similar to my own delegates.
I'm sorry to say I remember when e-mail first was introduced where I worked - the fears were exactly the same and I bet they said the same about the contraption invented by Alexander Graham Bell! Now look where we are.
Yes - there is no stopping it so if you can't beat 'em, join 'em is what I say!
But what is the "tangible" returns that internal L&D people can highlight to their budget holders to show that the impacts are real? Where is the empirical case studies? Do they exist or is it all consultant hype?
ReplyDeleteGreat post! I too remember when email first hit the work place and all the hub-bub. Like any new part of technology, there are always fears, but in the long run we come to depend upon it in the end. Just like email, we would be lost without it!
ReplyDeleteSandra
Hi Clive - I liked your pragmatic approach and the four areas. I have done a 'post-match' version of our debate for anyone interested: http://bit.ly/aR2gQP
ReplyDeleteIn the real world aspect of the teacher is part of what is transmitted.
ReplyDeleteIn the virtual world tner there are other points to consider:
Puntialidad response
Automatism
Affective Expreseiones
Misspellings
Quotes and links.
Graphic presentation
Expressions of voice ...
I think these aspects are very important.
#PLENK2010
I enjoy interpreting your thoughts on formal learning versus non-formal learning. As a visual art teacher at a kindergarten through eighth grade school, I am embracing technology and the use of social media as teaching tools. As you suggest, using these to learn will help, not hinder education. In my school, we are leaning more toward using strategies and technologies that are up and coming. No matter how much people try to resist using new technologies, young people ARE using them and we must embrace these new technologies as new ways people learn. You blog primarily about business organizations, however, instructional design happens everywhere, especially in schools. Thank you for enlightening me with this knowledge.
ReplyDelete