In December of 2008 I started using Twitter on a three-month trial basis. At the end of this period I reviewed my experience and devided to continue (see Three months a-Twittering). Just before Christmas I reached the one year milestone, at the same time posting my 1000th tweet and gaining my 1000th follower. So, what has all this activity achieved?
- I have stopped using my blog to share resources, provide updates or make brief comments - these have all graduated to Twitter. My blog has now taken the form of a more-or-less twice weekly column on learning-related issues, which works well for me.
- Twitter has provided me with a useful channel for notifying the learning community of my new blog postings, particularly for those readers who don’t subscribe through a feed.
- I have enjoyed playing my part in raising awareness of interesting postings and web articles that I have come across. Twitter is definitely accelerating the spread of useful information across the learning community and this has to be a good thing. I like the fact that people who have a generally low profile can still reach a very wide audience when they have something important to share.
- Twitter is one of the best and most rapid ways that I have yet encountered for obtaining answers to questions – what’s the best way to …? have you tried …? who’s available for …?
But I do have some misgivings:
- Having Twitter up-and-running on an ongoing basis seems to me to be highly disruptive if you’re trying to concentrate (see The Case Against Multi-tasking is growing). On my PC I get audible alerts from Twhirl when each new batch of tweets arrives and it takes a very disciplined person not to check what’s come in (and generally speaking I can resist anything except temptation). I know I could turn the alerts off, but instead I tend to leave Twhirl turned off most of the time. When I’m out and about, on the other hand, I’m grateful for the chatter.
- I’m concerned that we’re all becoming very good at passing interesting information on from one to another, but not actually reading and reflecting on any of it. It’s like making a recording of a TV programme – somehow it feels like that’s a job done, even if you don’t ever play it back.
- Twitter seems to have very limited usefulness as a vehicle for discussion. Once a dialogue extends beyond a few tweets, there’s simply too much traffic passing between a very limited subset of the community. I’ve kept the number of people that I follow down as much as I can (although it does stand at over 100) in order to maximise the signal-to-noise ratio, but I’ve still had to un-follow a few colleagues who seem to bombard the network with tweets from morning to night – how do they ever get any work done?
So let’s give it another go for another year and another 1000 tweets. One thing’s for sure, the way we all use Twitter will have moved on again and quite unpredictably.
Really good to read this Clive. It chimes with a discussion I was having yesterday about the adverse impact (on my behaviour certainly, and, as I see it on others' output as well). I am half persuaded that FriendFeed is a better half-way house as it permits a more reflective style, allows comments, and can feed through to (and from) Twitter and other sources. However the fact that different people use it in different ways, which makes for some frustrating inconsistency. And it is now owned by Facebook.
ReplyDeleteSeb
I have been using Twitter on a personal level for almost 2 years now (@TalTalK), and I find that it has replaced many of my searches. I often ask my Twitter followers for recommendations. It's not that I can't Google what collaboration tools are out there - but my followers use them and can tell me why they like the ones they like (or hate the ones they hate).
ReplyDeleteOn a professional level (@Sparkeo), at my current company we are in beta, so haven't been utilizing Twitter as much yet, but in past companies I found Twitter to be a great way to take care of problems quickly.
I usually had the Twitter Search page open with certain terms, including our company name, URL, and the main competition, and was able to put out fires quickly, even without having someone turn to us directly. It's a great tool to both learn on a personal level, and keep track of what is said about you professionally.
Interesting perspective. I signed up for Twitter about 6 months ago. I was unable to get it signed up to my phone and unable to access it from my workplace network, so that limited my use. Even though up till now fairly inactive, I signed up to follow some folk...you included, and have had a steady stream (ok...slow trickle) of followers. As I dont tweet much, I am amazed they sign up at all.
ReplyDeleteAnyway. My Twitter signup was an experiment too. I wanted to see how useful it was and how I might incorporate it into my work and external activities (singer/songwriter.) "Another Friday Night spent online...Its really taking up all your time" (Alex Watson aka s0ngb1rd :-))
Anyhow. Like you stated in your post...I have low attention span and patience..and with so much info, you have to be selective. This is indicitive of our age. However, if I am to become expert...I must put the time in.
Anyway. Thanks for all you wonderful blogs(I've read many of those) So much information...much of which I have followed through.
I bought Slide:ology, Got a Delicious account, signed up for Twitter, Got a Ning, Already had a Linkedin, Facebook and Myspace.Signed up to slideshare and youtube, Moodle, Wikipedia. Even Voicethread and BlogTalkRadio (i don't think those were from you...perhaps Jane Hart...who knows) what I didn't do is use them much, and I think you'll agree...thats alot of different communities to contend with. All the while trying to develop E-learning, Training and Deliver to Clients.
Having read this made me think about the way I have been using Twitter - and Facebook and my blog for that matter.
ReplyDeleteWhat you write about not reading and reflecting on the articles we read, is semi-true. As I try to take the time to read through all my newspaper and blog feeds every day, reading them thoroughly simply takes too much time. I must admit that we might unlearn to read articles in detail, but it certainly adds to our learning to skim through articles and find the essence of it that way.
After taking a look at my own Twitter stats, it seems that I have only 9 followers, and I am following 10 people myself. That doesn't make for very high numbers now, does it? I would attribute this to the fact that very few of my close friends or fellow students actually use Twitter, and thus both the following and followers count remains this low.
Do you think there is a way to make this feature popular amongst people in my age group? It sounds weird, but very few of them are interested in anything other than Facebook. Their interest in internet and IT are very limited, and I feel it is my task as a computer nerd to refer them to our side...
I hereby end this very random comment on this very random blog I ran into... through Twitter.
Kind regards,
Amy
I too joined Twitter In December 2008. And this has been a very interesting post to read. I closely identify with the points you have made.
ReplyDeleteI strongly agree with two of the points here:
1. Twitter can be disruptive (these days, I check Twitter twice a day--early morning and around 10:00 pm. I realized I was falling behind in my reading because of the compulsion to check Twitter ever so often...
2. Sometimes, it can lead to retweeting but not actual reading, reflection and giving of inputs on the articles, posts, etc.
However, Twitter has escalated my learning opportunities and reach manifold and has introduced me to (made it possible to be a part of) communities like #lrnchat.
Exercising self-discipline becomes important (I am struggling here) but Twitter has opened up a whole new world of learning and sharing for me...
I have begun to use Twitter like a real time search engine as well and it is faster and much more accurate. I not only get the links but also insights that add to/give different perspectives to what I am looking for...
As an English teacher,I have been trying to embrace all the emerging digital "literary" forms that my students spend time engaged in. As you point out Clive, Twitter is impressive as a disseminator of information, but I have one suspicion that I haven't been able to shake, a suspicion that will probably identify me as hopelessly out of touch with the pace and trends of today. As another of the commentators mention, one is almost compelled to skim rather than read for depth when following more than a few sources with Twitter. It isn't as if Twitter is alone as a modern media/medium used/abused as brief, instantaneous communication of too often dubious significance. My students, by and large, are plugged in to instant messaging, text, Twitter, etc. during their every waking moment. Many of them go through visible withdrawal when asked to put the phone away during class. Perhaps I am imaging things, but teaching students to read subtext, allegory, and even theme seems to be increasingly difficult. Students who spend hours of their day texting tell me they aren't readers or writers and I hate to say that in many cases I have to agree. Shouldn't time spent reading and writing improve performance in a literature classroom? I worry that those same students have to unlearn many of the reading habits that they develop through texts, Twitter, IM and so on in order to improve their reading of literature (especially fiction). Maybe some of those who read this post will see my concern as, at best, quaint and, at worst, backward. Perhaps my love of literature is absurdely obsolete. When students who never put down their smart phone ask why should they learn to read for theme, for allusion, for satire, when will they use such skills?--I wish I could feel more certain that (despite their endless phone chirps and blinding querty type speed) they ever will.
ReplyDeleteHi Clive, following your lead, I too decided to experiment with Twitter about a year ago. Never having been a great social animal anyway, I could never see the attraction of using these social media tools for 'fun'. I had signed up to Facebook ages before but hardly ever logged in (who are these people who claim to know me?).
ReplyDeleteHowever, seeing the potential I took a deep breath and signed up for Twitter too. I have found Twitter, in particular, very useful in keeping up to date with what is going on in the world of learning technologies. I'm now a big fan but I think you have to decide what you want to use it for.
I agree totally with the problems of interruptions. I use Tweetdeck for my desktop and find this useful to categorise the tweets coming in but I do get distracted by the 'bings' sometimes (I'm easily distracted) so have learned to ignor these. Turning the sound off helps.
I'm afraid I am guilty of being one of those selfish people and just absorb the information and rarely contributed and use it mainly to pass on what I feel interesting information to my followers. I'm slowly coming out of my hermit shell and starting to contribute (as you can see :o) ).
It's not all work though - I do follow (and unfollowed) various celebrities just for fun.
I've started to like Facebook too but do wonder why people play such silly games on it. There are some great groups and it has widened my connections within the archery circuit.
I think I will persevere - you never know I may eventually become a social animal (albeit virtually).
Thanks for such great posts.
Laura
Interesting comments Clive, I agree with the information pass on Twitter allows this to happen on a larger and faster scale than anything before it, the same thing happens with emails.
ReplyDeleteThanks for highlighting these different aspects of Twitter. Like other commenters, I started it at about the same time as you to see what it offered. I see the benefit occasionally, when I go into Tweetdeck (or now a sidebar in Firefox) and follow a link someone's put up. BUT, and it's a big but, I have to have it hidden away like that because I don't want to be interrupted or distracted. So I usually forget to go in! I've had to unfollow some people who seem to tweet something every ten minutes. Another thing I don't like is the email every day or two telling me about a new follower which turns out to be a porn site. What did I do to invite such enthusiastic invitations? So I kind of see the point of it, but can't quite like it.
ReplyDeleteI will admit that I am not a neophyte and that I only embrace new technology when I have an immediate use for it, but reading everyone's comments regarding Twitter has made me realize that before I can criticize or assess what effect new mediums like Twitter may or may not be having on the academic performance of students in my classroom, I'll need to sample it for myself. Thank you all for your insights.
ReplyDeleteInteresting topic
ReplyDeleteI've been on twitter for over a year now. I have some of the same feelings - I love how easy it is to connect with people, and how fast things can go viral. I love seeing instant reactions and feedback to my tweets.
ReplyDeleteBut therein lies the downfall - it's instantaneous, so it's a constant distraction. I think it's good that you cut down the number of your followers. It gets hard to keep track of everyone past a certain point. Twitter says that point is once you hit 1,000 followers, but I don't see how anyone could keep up with even that many.
I have been visiting various blogs for my term papers writing research. I have found your blog to be quite useful. Keep updating your blog with valuable information... Regards
ReplyDelete