Sometimes you feel you're being drawn into a battle and you're not sure why. A good example can be found in the animosity that the celtic fringe (Wales, Scotland, Ireland) feel towards the English. Their feelings are perfectly understandable, of course, given the dominating behaviour over many centuries of the Anglo-Saxons, but are not mirrored by the English, whose attention is more focused on those who they, in turn, wish not to be dominated by (the Americans perhaps). It's a one-sided battle, because only one side is angry and up for a fight. I, for one, have no strong feelings one way or other about the Welsh, Irish or Scottish. I wish them well, except, of course, when they play England in any sporting contest.
I encounter a similar situation when I come across Mac users and Apple aficionados generally. When they find out I'm a PC user, they seem up for a fight. I don't have any problem with the fact that they wish to spend a lot more on their computers. I understand that Apple is a more stylish brand and that some people feel it is worth paying more for the prestige that this reflects upon them. Good for them, but their religious zeal is lost on PC users, who have no problems with Windows and the Office suite, which do more than enough for them and are much more reliable than Apple users think (particularly now we have Windows 7).
It's not as if it's an ethical issue. After all, both Microsoft and Apple aspire to a monopolistic status in their markets, as do all capitalist ventures. Both have achieved this (one with operating systems and office applications, one with MP3 players and perhaps eventually with smart phones). It's the job of regulators to make this position difficult to accomplish or to maintain.
And Microsoft and Apple are not even direct competitors. One is predominantly a software company and one is mainly hardware. A much more important battle is the one they both face against free and open source software.
To show just how one-sided these wars have become, most PC users are perfectly happy to buy iPods and the English are happy to holiday in Wales, whereas you won't often see a Mac user buying a phone running Windows Mobile or a Scotsman cheering on England playing Germany at football. But all this negative energy is wasted. There are battles out there that really are worth fighting.
But surely Clive you are just adding fuel to the debate. The main reason why people use Macs is not because of the expense but aside from their aesthetic side they are just so easy, nay intuitive, to use and they hardly ever crash!
ReplyDeleteStill, each to their own, that's what I say!
Judith
I agree with your post.. although it seems a bit biased towards PCs. I use a PC and I like both PC and mac. Mac's seem to have a better screen resolution and things do seem to run better on it... but a lot of programs won't run on a mac. I definitely agree about it being a battle that doesn't need to be fought.. I don't really understand why some people are either very for PC and against mac or the other way around. I'm just confused as to why Apple doesn't want to support flash on their mobile devices.
ReplyDeleteI use both mac and pc - the mac purchase had nothing to do with "the prestige this reflects" on me.
ReplyDeleteI love your posts generally but must admit I'm a little mystified as to the the thinking behind this one. It must be the irrational "celtic fringe" in me!
I have an old PC and a slightly newer Mac laptop at home. I am fine with both. As someone who is about to purchase a shiny new 27" iMac, I'm still going to be running Windows via Bootcamp on it. There are some things I just cannot run on OS X, or that I'm forced into Windows for due to licensing.
ReplyDeleteI'm fine with both myself, and my Windows PC until recently has been quite reliable (thought I'm ashamed to be over 2 years going on an XP install, which is part of my problem). I'm partly switching for a number of reasons, but the iMac's spec and price is one of them. Can't beat a huge screen with a sizable second either.
Hmmm. Picking your battles. People are always going to like what they like, and for some reason...are always trying to convince others of its merits. Whether this be MAC or PC, taste in Music, Fashion, Food etc. Each to his own I say. But I must say, as someone who uses both PC and MAC in the past....MAC users are far more evangalistic than PC users......maybe they feel they are onto a good thing and don't mind spreading the gospel. Isn't this what word of mouth promotion is all about?
ReplyDeleteAs for jingoism, patriotism etc. It's great to be proud of where you are from. For some nations that is a history of fighting oppression which then meshes itself into the charateristics of the people......Forgive :-)
I really enjoyed your post, and agree wholeheartedly. I've worked with both a Mac and a PC, and don't really see what the big deal is. Macs are fine, but they are very overpriced, and I've often felt the same way about the iPods and iPhones as well. As a graduate student in the field of Instructional Technology, I've often walked into class with my PC only to be teased by my Mac-toting colleagues. I was really amused by your comparison to the feeling between the English and the Scots; speaking as an American of Scottish descent, it was a very clever comparison and very true.
ReplyDelete